|
Preventing Employee Pilferage
Not all crooks roam the streets of
the nation's cities. Many spend their time in the manufacturing plants of
companies. There, disguised as honest citizens, they pilfer whatever comes
to hand, often tampering with records to cover up their thefts.
To prevent pilferage, an owner-manager must recognize that some
employees cannot be trusted and make all employees aware that he or she is
taking steps to thwart dishonest personnel. Such steps include setting up
a system of loss prevention (devices and procedures), administering the
system rigidly, and auditing it often to discourage dishonest employees
who try to bypass the system.
To steal or not to steal? That is the question facing employees in
plants. Many employees answer that question almost unconsciously. They see
items lying around and pick them up for their own use. They slip small
hand tools into their pockets. Or they dip into the bin for a fistful of
nuts and bolts or snip off a few feet of wire for a home repair job.
But not all employees who pilfer are nickel-and-dime thieves. Some are
professionals who carry off thousands of dollars worth of equipment and
materials.
Misplaced Trust
One reason for pilferage is misplaced trust. Many owner-managers of
small companies feel close to their employees. Some regard their employees
as partners. These owner-managers trust their people with keys, a safe
combination, cash, and records.
Thus, these employees have at hand the tools which a thief or embezzler
needs for a successful crime.
Unfortunately, some of the "trusted" employees in many small businesses
are larger partners than their bosses anticipate. Unless you're taking
active steps to prevent loss from in-plant pilferage, some are probably
trying to steal your business, little by little, right from under your
nose. Few indeed are the businesses in which dishonest employees are not
busily at work. Usually, these employees are protected by management's
indifference or ineptitude as they steal a little, steal a lot, but
nevertheless, steal first the profit, and then the business itself.
One of the first steps in preventing pilferage is for the owner-manager
to examine the trust he or she puts in employees. Is it blind trust that
grew from close friendships? Or is it trust that is built on an
accountability that reduces opportunities for thefts?
A Climate for Dishonesty
In addition to misplacing trust, it is easy for an owner-manager to
create an environment in which dishonesty takes root and thrives. Just
relax your accounting and inventory control procedures. Nothing deters
would-be thieves like the knowledge that inventory is so closely
controlled that stolen goods will be missed quickly.
And what about the plant where its common practice for a close relative
or two of the boss to help themselves from the stockroom without signing
for the items they take? Soon such a plant becomes a place where inventory
shrinkage soars as employees get the message that recordkeeping is loose
and controls are lax.
In a manufacturing plant, no materials and no finished goods should be
taken without a requisition or a removal record being made. Exceptions?
Absolutely none.
Similarly, the owner-manager who does not exercise tight control over
invoices, purchase orders, removals (for example, for tools, materials,
and finished goods), and credits is asking for embezzlement, fraud, and
unbridled theft. Crooked office workers and production and maintenance
personnel dream about sloppily kept records and un-watched inventory. Why
make their dreams come true?
One shipping platform employee's dream came true to the tune of $30,000
- the amount of goods he stole from his company. When caught, he said, "It
was so easy, I really didn't think anyone cared."
Let people know you care. Make them aware of the stress you place on
loss-prevention.
This point must be driven home again and again. And with every
restatement of It - whether by a security check, a change of locks, the
testing of alarms, a systems audit, a notice on the bulletin board - you
can be assured that you are influencing that moment of decision when an
employee is faced with the choice-to steal or not to steal.
Haphazard Physical Security
Also high on the list of invitations to theft is haphazard physical
security. Owner-managers who are casual about issuing keys, locking doors,
and changing locks are, in effect, inviting the dishonest employee into
the plant or office after work. But intelligent key control and
installation of timelocks and alarms are ways of serving notice to crooked
workers to play it straight.
Sometimes profits go out the window - literally. For example, one
distributor caught "trusted" employees lowering TV sets and tape recorders
from a third-story warehouse window to confederates below. Unfortunately
they were not caught until they had milked their boss of thousands of
dollars worth of merchandise.
But more often, the industrial thief uses a door rather than a window.
And the more doors a plant has, the more avenues of theft it offers.
The plant that's designed for maximum security will have a minimum
number of active doors and a supervisor or guard, if warranted, stationed
near each door. Moreover, a supervisor should be present when materials or
finished goods are being received or shipped and when trash is being
removed. As long as a door stays open, a responsible employee, a
supervisor, or a guard should be there.
Central station alarm systems should be used to protect a plant after
hours. Their purpose is to record door openings and closings and to
investigate unexpected openings. Timelocks are also designed to record all
openings.
"Breaking-out"
A record of door openings can be important because the dishonest
employee is often a specialist at "breaking out" (hiding and leaving the
plant after closing hours). If your plant is not protected against
break-out, you can be hurt badly because this method of operation allows a
thief to work pretty much at his or her own speed.
After-hours thieves put out of commission the alarm system that works
beautifully against break-in. They can often leave by doors equipped with
snap-type locks-doors that do not require keys from the insides. Quickly
and easily, they can pass goods outside and then snap doors closed behind
them. Thus, they leave no evidence.
A motion detector, electric eye, or central station alarm will deter
such thieves. You can also discourage break-outs with locks that need keys
on both sides, provided that fire regulations do not prohibit such locks.
When goods, materials, or money are missing and evidence of forced entry
is lacking, begin to look immediately for the inside thief, the dishonest
employee.
Audit Control Methods
Loss prevention controls and procedures by themselves are not enough to
protect your assets. Controls and procedures must be audited from time to
time or they will break down. No loss-prevention control is stronger than
its audit.
One effective auditing method is to commit deliberate errors. What will
your people do if, for example, you see that more finished goods than the
shipping order calls for reach the platform? Will the shipping clerk
return the excess to stock? Will he or she try to divert it for personal
use (perhaps in collusion with a truck driver)? Or will the clerk simply
ship the order without ever knowing that the excess existed?
If the bookkeeper and the accounts receivable clerk are not dependable,
alert, and honest, disaster can result. Check them by withholding an
invoice from each of them and watching to see what they do. Will they miss
the invoice? Will they realize that a missing invoice means lost revenue
and call it to your attention?
Unannounced inspections are another excellent method of checking your
preventive procedures. Such inspections are most effective during overtime
periods or when the second or third shift is working. For example, one
owner-manager popped up on the shipping platform after the second shift
left. He noticed a loaded truck parked at the platform and ordered it
unloaded. The cartons in the rear were legitimate deliveries, but he found
the front half of the truck crammed with stolen goods. The checker, who
was hired to see that such stealing did not happen, had gone to sleep and
let the accommodating driver load his own truck.
Influence Employees
You should never underestimate your ability to influence your employees
in the direction of honesty. Your use of good controls, stiff
loss-prevention procedures, and cleverly located physical security devices
are powerful reminders to employees that the boss does indeed care.
But controls and devices can be wasted if the owner-manager fails to
set a personal example of honesty and conscientiousness. A personal
example of high integrity by the boss is the most important step in
demonstrating to employees that dishonesty is intolerable.
Such an example includes following the same loss prevention rules that
apply to employees. For instance, the owner-manager should sign for items
he or she takes from the stockroom just like any other person.
Keep Crooks Off Balance
The crooked employees who are the most successful at their "second
trade" are the ones who test the system and are convinced that they can
beat it. They can steal you blind. With every "score," their confidence
increases and along with it their danger to the company. The best way to
stop such crooks is to keep them off balance - keep them from developing
the feeling that they can beat your system.
Here's an example of how one owner-manager keeps crooks off balance.
When inventory shrinkage became a major problem, he made a loss-prevention
survey. To help keep employees honest, he tightened certain existing
controls and put in some new ones. He reduced the number of exits
employees could use by half. He scheduled "unscheduled" locker inspections
for the unlikeliest possible moments. Employees were no longer allowed to
take lunch boxes or bags of any kind to their work stations. Package
inspection procedures were tightened.
To date, this owner-manager has caught no thieves. But by simply
tightening controls and adding a number of surprise elements to his
loss-prevention maintenance system, he reduced his inventory loss
drastically.
Don't Play Detective
Dishonest employees, working alone or in collusion with others, can
find ways to beat the system no matter how theft-proof you try to make it.
"Smart cookies" can devise ways to get away with substantial amounts of
money, materials, or goods.
Owner-managers who suspect theft should not attempt to turn detective
and try to solve the crimes themselves.
Even the best business owner may botch a criminal investigation because
it's an area in which the average owner is an amateur.
When you suspect a theft, bring the police or a reliable firm of
professional security consultants into the picture without delay. Where
dishonest employees are bonded by insurance companies, ironclad evidence
of theft must be uncovered before you can file a claim with the insurance
company to recover your losses. Professional undercover investigation is
among the most effective ways to secure such evidence.
Rules Can Help Reduce Pilferage
Employees who are caught stealing will be prosecuted. (Settling for
restitution and an apology is inviting theft to continue.)
Rotate security guards. (Rotation discourages fraternizing with other
employees who may turn out to be dishonest. Rotation also prevents
monotony from reducing the alertness of guards.)
Never assign two or more members of the same family to work in the same
area. (You can expect blood to be thicker than company loyalty.)
Key employees will be kept informed about the activities and findings
of the person who is in charge of security. (Thus weak points in security
can be strengthened without delay.)
Make a dependable second check of incoming materials to rule out the
possibility of collusive theft between drivers and employees who handle
the receiving:
No truck shall approach the loading platform until it is ready to load
or unload.
Drivers will not be allowed behind the receiving fence. (Discourage
drivers from taking goods or materials from the platform by the following
devices: heavy-gauge wire fencing between bays, with the mesh too fine to
provide a toehold; closed-circuit television cameras, mounted overhead so
as to sweep the entire platform; and locating the receiving supervisor's
desk or office to afford him or her an unobstructed view of the entire
platform.)
At the loading platform, drivers will not be permitted to load their
own trucks, especially by taking goods from stock.
Every lunchbox, tool box, bag, or package must be inspected by a
supervisor or guard as employees leave the plant.
All padlocks must be snapped shut on hasps when not in use to prevent
the switching of locks.
Keys to padlocks must be controlled. Never leave the key hanging on a
nail near the lock where a crooked worker can "borrow" it and have a
duplicate made while he or she is away from work.
Trash must not be allowed to accumulate in, or be picked up from, an
area near storage sites of valuable materials or finished goods.
Inspect disposal locations and rubbish trucks at irregular intervals
for the presence of salable items when you have the slightest reason to
suspect collusion between employees and trash collectors.
Trash pickups must be supervised. (Companies have been systematically
drained over long periods by alliance between crooked employees and trash
collectors.)
Control receiving reports and shipping orders (preferably by numbers in
sequence) to prevent duplication of fraudulent payment of invoices and the
padding or destruction of shipping orders.
Receiving reports must be prepared immediately upon receiving a
shipment. (Delay in making out such reports can be an invitation to theft
or, at best, result in recordkeeping errors.)
Food For Thought
Have you ever noticed what
happens right before you're going on a long-awaited vacation? If
you're like most people, you are bulletproof. Nothing gets you down.
You cheerfully work harder than usual to get things ready for your
trip, and to arrange for everything to continue smoothly while you are
gone. In fact, for many people, the day before leaving on vacation is
often the most productive day they have all year.
Why is that? Well, for one thing, you HAVE to get the work done. You
have a sense of urgency. It won't wait until tomorrow. So you're
extremely motivated in that regard. You also have a "light at the end
of the tunnel." You know that tomorrow you'll be relaxing on the
beach, or hiking through the mountains, and that is enough to keep you
going at a high level of energy and enthusiasm.
Wouldn't it be great if every day could be like that? Just think how
much you would accomplish.
When you think about it, the day before vacation is no different than
any other day. The only thing that makes it different is your
attitude. Guess what? You're in complete control of your attitude.
So... if you really want, you can feel that way every day.
The trick is to find something exciting and inspiring to look forward
to. Yes, a vacation is great, but you can't do that every day. That's
where your goals come into play.
What is your life's dream? What excites you, and motivates you, and
inspires you more than anything else? Whatever it is, you need to
constantly remind yourself of it. Keep it at the front of your mind.
Know that everything you are doing is leading to that goal.
Goals aren't really important for what they are, so much as for what
they help you to become. In fact, reaching your goal is not nearly as
important as what you do, and what you become, in the process. We are
goal seeking creatures. We need something to strive for, to look
forward to. Provide that for yourself, and every day can be joyous and
productive.
Ask yourself: are you living the life you choose? The answer is...
Yes!
Because what you are, what you have, and what you do are all the
result of choices you have made. You are where you are right now
because of what you have chosen. If you don't like where you are, you
can waste a lot of time, effort and energy blaming someone or
something for your situation. We all have obstacles, though, and
success in life is based primarily on whether we chose to see those
obstacles as excuses or as challenges. It makes all the difference in
the world.
Your life is determined by your choices. You can chose to sit around
all night watching TV, or you can choose to spend your evening
enriching your mind, perhaps learning a new skill. You can choose to
dull your senses with drugs and alcohol, or you can choose to keep
your body in top shape with challenging exercise. You can choose to
stand quietly in the corner at the party, or to use it as an
opportunity to meet interesting people.
Surprisingly, the important choices aren't the big ones. It is the
cumulative effect of the little choices that makes the biggest
difference. We may agonize for weeks or months over what school to
attend, what career to pursue or what job offer to accept. These are
what we consider big, important choices. In reality, though, our life
is determined more by the "little" choices that we make every day:
Should I make that extra phone call? Should I volunteer for that
project? Should I introduce myself to the new department manager?
Should I have another piece of cheesecake? Should I roll over and
sleep for another 20 minutes? Should I watch that re-run of Sienfeld
for the 4th time?
Choices, not chances, determine our destiny. What do you choose?
Remember when you first learned to ride a bicycle? You probably used
training wheels.
Training wheels made it safer and more comfortable for you to learn.
They kept you from falling. They helped you to gain a little
confidence. Then it was time to take off the training wheels -- a
traumatic experience.
All of a sudden you were exposed to the risk of falling. You had to
keep your own balance. There was nothing to fall back on. And yet with
a little bit of determination, you learned how to do it. And then what
you felt was...
Freedom! Now you could ride up the driveway, down the sidewalk,
through the fields, along the street. You could lean into turns and
feel the wind in your face. You could speed down hills and fly off the
curb. It was wonderful and exhilirating. Once you learned to ride
without the training wheels, you never wanted or needed them again.
Are you living your life with the training wheels on? Are you nestled
safely inside your comfort zone, with your job and your mortgage and
your HMO and your daily routine keeping you nice and secure? Do you
even know what you're missing?
Is your fear keeping you from following your dreams? What are you
afraid of? Going after your biggest dream is no more difficult than
safely living inside your comfort zone. And it is infinitely more
rewarding.
Riding your bicycle without the training wheels soon became even
easier than riding with them on, and a whole lot more fun. You never
would have known that, though, if you had not tried.
Are you too afraid to take the training wheels off? What's the worst
that can happen? The worst that can happen, will happen for sure if
you DON'T take them off. The worst that can happen is that you'll get
to the end of your life never having known the excitement of challenge
or the thrill of accomplishment.
Make the commitment today to grab those handlebars and head out on the
road of life! |
|