|
Preventing Embezzlement
An owner-manager can loose a great deal of money before even suspecting
that embezzlement might be going on. That's because by definition this
crime is committed by someone in a position of trust. The loss may involve
a small amount taken by an employee from the cash register. Or a
considerable sum stolen through an elaborate scheme of juggling the books.
Simple controls built into the accounting system can often forestall
any such practices in your operation. In any case, the proper internal
controls may help document incriminating evidence, without which it is
difficult to estimate your loss for insurance purposes or even to prove
that it resulted from a crime.
This Guide offers suggestions on how you can thwart dishonest
practices. It also discusses what you should do if it appears that one of
your employees has embezzled from your business.
You may not have has any experience with embezzlers. But many
owner-managers have. Everyday there are newspaper stories about how some
dishonest employee has managed to divert company funds to his or her own
pocket. It happens often enough to make it worth your while to give the
subject some thought and to examine your recordkeeping and auditing
procedures to make sure there are no tempting loopholes.
Embezzlement is "the fraudulent appropriation of property by a person
to whom it has been entrusted." That's what makes this crime different
from ordinary theft or larceny. The embezzler is someone in your company
whom you trust.
You need to have a system of internal control to safeguard money and
other property subject to embezzlement. Of course, nobody wants to run a
business like an armed camp. But if you have a built-in control system,
administer it tightly, and audit it frequently, you may prevent attempts
of embezzlement. At any rate, you will have the means to collect evidence
that may expose a crime.
Embezzlers usually think that they are clever - smarter than the
owner-manager and cunning enough to beat the system. Before you set about
to outwit them, it is a good idea to be familiar with some of their
methods
Some Common Schemes
The embezzler is usually a trusted employee who is taking advantage of
the employer's confidence. In many cases the embezzler has been given more
authority than the position calls for. Methods of embezzling are limited
only by imagination.
In the simplest situation, cash is received and the employee merely
pockets it without making a record of the transaction. A theft of this
type is difficult to prevent or detect if the transaction is a cash sale
and no subsequent entry is necessary in receipt or accounts receivable
records. To reduce temptation, prenumbered sales invoices or cash receipts
should be used for all sales regardless of the amount. Spot checks and
other monitoring procedures can also help assure you that cash sales are
actually being recorded.
A somewhat more complicated type of embezzlement is called lapping.
This involves the temporary withholding of receipts such as payments on
accounts receivable. Lapping is a continuing scheme which usually starts
with a small amount but can run into thousands of dollars before it is
detected. For example, take an employee who opens mail or otherwise
receives cash and checks as payment on open accounts. The employee holds
out a $100 dollar cash payment made by customer "A" on March 1. To avoid
arousing suspicion on "A's" part, $100 is then taken from a $200 payment
made by customer "B" on March 4. This is sent on, together with the
necessary documentation, for processing and crediting to the account of
"A." The embezzler pockets the remaining $100, which increases the
shortage to $200.
As this "borrowing" procedure continues, the employee makes away with
increasingly larger amounts of money involving more and more accounts. A
fraud of this nature can run on for years. Of course, it requires detailed
recordkeeping by the embezzler in order to keep track of the shortage and
transfer it from one account to another to avoid suspicion. Any indication
that an employee is keeping personal records of business transactions
outside your regular books of account should be looked into.
Sometimes an embezzler who is carrying on a lapping scheme also has
access to accounts receivable records and statements. In this case, he or
she is in a position to alter the statements mailed out to customers. Thus
the fraud may continue undetected over a long period of time, until
something unusual happens. A customer complaint may spotlight the
situation. Or the matter may be surfaced through audit procedures such as
confirmation of accounts receivable. One embezzler who also handled the
customer complaints was able to avoid detection for many years. The amount
of shortage reached such proportions and covered so many accounts that he
dared not take a vacation. He even ate lunch at his desk lest some other
employee receive an inquiry from a customer concerning a discrepancy in a
statement. The owner-manager for whom he worked admired his diligence and
loyalty. Fellow workers marveled that his apparent frugality enable him to
enjoy a rather high standard of living. But the inevitable finally
happened. this employee was hospitalized with a serious ailment, and in
his absence his fraudulent scheme came to light. One reason many firms
require regular vacations is to keep some "indispensable man" from
dispensing with company funds illegally.
Sometimes company bank accounts are used for check-kiting. In fact,
losses from some large check-kiting schemes have been great enough to
cause a company to go broke.
In the usual scheme, the check-kiter must be in the position to write
checks on and make deposits in two or more bank accounts. One account
could be the embezzler's personal account and the other a business
checking account. If the embezzler has an accomplice in another business,
two business accounts may be used. If your company has more than one
checking account at different banks, these accounts may be utilized to
carry out the fraud.
The check-kiter is taking advantage of the time period (or "float")
which is the number of days between deposit of a check and collection of
funds. There may be several days between the date when a kited check drawn
on bank "A" is deposited in bank "B" and the date the check is presented
to the bank "A" for payment. Assuming that it takes 3 business days for
checks to clear, a simple kite between two banks could be accomplished as
follows:
On December 1, a check in the amount of $5,000 drawn on bank "A" is
deposited in bank "B." On December 2, the check-kiter cashes a $5,000
check payable to cash and drawn on bank "B" with a teller at bank "B."
Since the original kited check will be presented to bank "A" on December
4, the check kiter on or before that date will deposit a $6,000 check
drawn on bank "B" in bank "A" not only to insure payment of the original
kited check but to increase the amount of the kite. As the process is
repeated the kited checks become larger, more cash is withdrawn, and the
scheme can continue until the shortage is covered - or until the kite
"breaks" when one of the banks refuses to honor a kited check because the
funds on deposit are uncollected.
A temporary kite may be used by a dishonest employee to conceal cash
shortage at the end of a period by depositing a kited check into your
company account. This brings the bank balance into agreement with the
books. CPAs will request "cut-off" bank statements to detect frauds of
this type.
Payroll frauds are yet another source of loss to management.
Occasionally an enterprising embezzler has added the names of relatives or
fictitious individuals to the company payroll and thus enjoyed several
salary checks each week instead of one.
Sometimes, when a company becomes large enough that the owner-manager
can no longer exercise personal surveillance of accounting activities,
opportunities arise for a dishonest employee to set up a dummy supplier
and falsify documentation of fictitious purchase transactions.
Dishonest employees can figure out any number of ways to defraud their
employers. Purchasing agents can accept "kickbacks" from suppliers from
purchasing goods at inflated prices. Salespeople and others can pad their
expense accounts. Personal items can sometimes be bought and charged to
the company. Cashiers in retail firms can undercharge relatives or friends
for merchandise. False vouchers can be prepared to conceal thefts from
petty cash funds. Overtime can be falsely recorded. Moreover, quite
substantial amounts of money may be lost through the cumulative effect of
such seemingly minor abuses as personal use of company postage stamps,
supplies, and equipment, as well as charging personal long-distance phone
calls to the business. And so on.
Make Your System Fraud-Proof
The first and one of the most important things an owner-manager should
do is to set a good example. Your employees watch what you do and are
prone to imitate your habits - good or bad. An employer who dips into
petty cash, fudges on an expense account, uses company funds for personal
items, or sets other examples of loose business behavior will find
employees rationalizing dishonest actions with the attitude "if it's good
enough for the boss, its good enough for me."
Another important way an owner-manager can discourage embezzlement is
by establishing a climate of accountability. Employees should know their
jobs and feel trusted. But they should also realize that they are held
accountable for their actions. To some people, management indifference in
financial administration is a license to steal. That's why it is important
for you to examine your procedures and determine what controls can be
added to forestall any dishonest practices. And, just as important, the
system should be designed to help document evidence in the event someone
does try to embezzle your funds. One problem in fidelity loss claims is
that of proving the amount that was stolen. The owner-manager has to
support a loss claim with evidence - facts and figures that you get from
your records.
Reliance for prevention and detection of fraud must be placed
principally upon an adequate accounting system with appropriate internal
controls that safeguard your assets. Your public accountant can be of
great help in setting up a good recordkeeping system. Then it must be
tested and evaluated at least annually by the auditor. The purpose of
periodic examination is to make sure that there are no loopholes through
which an embezzler can manipulate your funds.
One fundamental control is separation of the duties of employees. For
example, persons concerned with receiving checks and cash should not also
be responsible for the entries in the accounts receivable records. No one
person should handle a transaction from beginning to end. If you do not
exercise tight control over invoices, purchase orders, discounts, customer
credits, and so forth, you are asking for trouble.
You should insist that your accounting system provide you with
operating statements issued at least monthly. These will inform you of the
operations to date and the firm's financial condition. You can use these
documents to compare the figures with prior periods. Any unusual or
unexplained variations should be discussed with your public accountant to
determine the reason.
Look For Clues
You know how in medicine the symptoms of one disease often resemble
those of another. Likewise in business the symptoms, or danger signs, of
an embezzlement are often caused by other factors. Here are a few clues
which indicate that either an embezzler is at work in your company or
certain aspects of the business need more of your attention.
Increase in overall sales returns could be caused by defective
merchandise - or it might represent a concealment of accounts receivable
payments.
Unusual bed-debt write-offs can be due to a number of business reasons
- or they could be covering up a fraudulent scheme.
A decline or usually small increase in cash or credit sales might mean
that business has not been good - or it could mean that some sales were
not being recorded.
Inventory shortage can be caused by error or mismanagement - or they
could indicate fictitious purchases, unrecorded sales, or employee
pilferage.
Profit declines and/or increases in expenses can be entirely legitimate
- or they could be a sign that cash is being siphoned off illegitimately.
Slow collections can be caused by business conditions - or they can be
a device to mask an embezzlement.
Ounces Of Prevention
There are many steps an owner-manager can take to cut down on the
possibility of losses through embezzlement. Do you take the following
precautions?
1. Check the background of prospective employees. Sometimes you can
satisfy yourself by making a few telephone calls or writing a few letters.
In other cases, you may want to turn the matter over to a credit bureau or
similar agency to run a background check. (Keep in mind that the rights of
individuals must be preserved in furnishing, receiving, and using
background information).
2. Know your employees to the extent that you may be able to detect
signs of financial or personal problems. Build up rapport so that they
feel free to discuss such things with you in confidence.
3. See that no one is placed on the payroll without authorization from
you or a responsible official of the company. If you have a personnel
department, require that it approve additions to the payroll as a double
check.
4. Have the company mail addressed to a post office box rather than to
your place of business. In smaller cities, the owner-manager may want to
go to the post office to collect the mail. In any event, you or your
designated key person should personally open the mail and make a record at
that time of cash and checks received. Don't delude yourself that checks
or money orders payable to your company can't be converted into cash by an
enterprising embezzler.
5. Either personally prepare the daily cash deposits or compare the
deposits made by employees with the record of cash and checks received.
Make sure you get a copy of the duplicate deposit slip or other
documentation from the bank. Make it a habit to go to the bank and make
the daily deposit yourself as often as you can. If you delegate these
jobs, make an occasional spot check to see that nothing is amiss.
6. Arrange for bank statements and other correspondence from banks to
be sent to the same post office box, and personally reconcile all bank
statements with your company's books and records. The owner-manager who
has not reconciled the statements for some time may want to get orientated
by the firm's outside accountant.
7. Personally examine all canceled checks and endorsements to see if
there is anything unusual. This also applies to payroll checks.
8. Make sure that an employee in a position to mishandle funds is
adequately bonded. Let employees know that fidelity coverage is a matter
of company policy rather that any feeling of mistrust on your part. If
would-be embezzlers know that a bonding company also has an interest in
what they do, they may think twice before helping themselves to your
funds.
9. Spot check your accounting records and assets to satisfy yourself
that all is well and that your plan of internal control is being carried
out.
10. Personally approve unusual discounts and bad-debt write-offs.
Approve or spot check credit memos and other documentation for sales
returns and allowances.
11. Don't delegate the signing of checks and approval of cash
disbursements unless absolutely necessary and never approve any payment
without sufficient documentation or prior knowledge of the transaction.
12. Examine all invoices and supporting data before signing checks.
Make sure that all merchandise was actually received and the price seems
reasonable. In many false purchase schemes, the embezzler neglects to make
up receiving forms or other records purporting to show receipt of
merchandise.
13. Personally cancel all invoices at the time you sign the check to
prevent double payment through error or otherwise.
14. Don't sign blank checks. Don't leave a supply of signed blank
checks when you go on vacation.
15. Inspect all prenumbered checkbooks and other prenumbered forms
from time to time to insure that checks or forms from the backs of the
books have not been removed and possibly used in a fraudulent scheme.
16. Have the preparation of the payroll and the actual paying of
employees handled by different persons, especially when cash is involved.
If You Suspect A Crime
First of all, be sure that you do not jump to any unwarranted
conclusions. What may appear to be an obvious embezzlement may, on further
investigation, turn out to have a perfectly valid explanation. A false
accusation could result in serious civil liability. There have been cases
where employees have been charged by management with embezzlement,
dismissed from their positions, and later found to be entirely innocent.
But if you have good reason to suspect embezzling, contact your
attorney immediately. Be guided by legal advice on how to proceed. Discuss
the necessity of notifying the bonding company and appropriate law
enforcement authorities. follow legal advice in matters regarding
prosecution so that you will not subject yourself or your company to
charges of false arrest.
Don't subject yourself to criminal charges by helping to conceal the
commission of a crime. Embezzlers should be prosecuted when the facts so
warrant and when there is a sufficiency of evidence. These and other legal
questions are best left to your attorney.
Computer-Related Embezzlements
The news media have given a lot of publicity to computer-assisted
frauds and embezzlements. The computer crimes receiving this publicity are
usually complex and give the impression that computers-related frauds can
be committed only by highly skilled technicians using sophisticated
computer systems. This could create a feeling of false security for
owner-managers who use less sophisticated systems or service centers for
processing their records.
A study by the U.S. General Accounting Office of Computer-Related
Crimes in Federal Programs disclosed that most computer-related crimes
were committed by people with limited knowledge of computer technology.
Most cases resulted from preparation of false input data to computer-based
systems. Neglect of control on input is a weakness. You should have your
outside accountant review your controls and strengthen it if needed.
To Sum Up
There are three principal ways in which you can minimize the
possibility of embezzlement losses. None is completely effective without
the others.
Internal controls are perhaps the most effective safeguard against
fraud, but even the best precautions can't make it absolutely impossible.
Independent audits discourage fraud and may uncover it. but they can't,
as some people mistakenly believe, guarantee disclosure of all
irregularities.
Fidelity coverage can help you recover what may be lost in spite of
your best efforts to prevent embezzlements.
Food For Thought
Have you ever noticed what
happens right before you're going on a long-awaited vacation? If
you're like most people, you are bulletproof. Nothing gets you down.
You cheerfully work harder than usual to get things ready for your
trip, and to arrange for everything to continue smoothly while you are
gone. In fact, for many people, the day before leaving on vacation is
often the most productive day they have all year.
Why is that? Well, for one thing, you HAVE to get the work done. You
have a sense of urgency. It won't wait until tomorrow. So you're
extremely motivated in that regard. You also have a "light at the end
of the tunnel." You know that tomorrow you'll be relaxing on the
beach, or hiking through the mountains, and that is enough to keep you
going at a high level of energy and enthusiasm.
Wouldn't it be great if every day could be like that? Just think how
much you would accomplish.
When you think about it, the day before vacation is no different than
any other day. The only thing that makes it different is your
attitude. Guess what? You're in complete control of your attitude.
So... if you really want, you can feel that way every day.
The trick is to find something exciting and inspiring to look forward
to. Yes, a vacation is great, but you can't do that every day. That's
where your goals come into play.
What is your life's dream? What excites you, and motivates you, and
inspires you more than anything else? Whatever it is, you need to
constantly remind yourself of it. Keep it at the front of your mind.
Know that everything you are doing is leading to that goal.
Goals aren't really important for what they are, so much as for what
they help you to become. In fact, reaching your goal is not nearly as
important as what you do, and what you become, in the process. We are
goal seeking creatures. We need something to strive for, to look
forward to. Provide that for yourself, and every day can be joyous and
productive.
Ask yourself: are you living the life you choose? The answer is...
Yes!
Because what you are, what you have, and what you do are all the
result of choices you have made. You are where you are right now
because of what you have chosen. If you don't like where you are, you
can waste a lot of time, effort and energy blaming someone or
something for your situation. We all have obstacles, though, and
success in life is based primarily on whether we chose to see those
obstacles as excuses or as challenges. It makes all the difference in
the world.
Your life is determined by your choices. You can chose to sit around
all night watching TV, or you can choose to spend your evening
enriching your mind, perhaps learning a new skill. You can choose to
dull your senses with drugs and alcohol, or you can choose to keep
your body in top shape with challenging exercise. You can choose to
stand quietly in the corner at the party, or to use it as an
opportunity to meet interesting people.
Surprisingly, the important choices aren't the big ones. It is the
cumulative effect of the little choices that makes the biggest
difference. We may agonize for weeks or months over what school to
attend, what career to pursue or what job offer to accept. These are
what we consider big, important choices. In reality, though, our life
is determined more by the "little" choices that we make every day:
Should I make that extra phone call? Should I volunteer for that
project? Should I introduce myself to the new department manager?
Should I have another piece of cheesecake? Should I roll over and
sleep for another 20 minutes? Should I watch that re-run of Sienfeld
for the 4th time?
Choices, not chances, determine our destiny. What do you choose?
Remember when you first learned to ride a bicycle? You probably used
training wheels.
Training wheels made it safer and more comfortable for you to learn.
They kept you from falling. They helped you to gain a little
confidence. Then it was time to take off the training wheels -- a
traumatic experience.
All of a sudden you were exposed to the risk of falling. You had to
keep your own balance. There was nothing to fall back on. And yet with
a little bit of determination, you learned how to do it. And then what
you felt was...
Freedom! Now you could ride up the driveway, down the sidewalk,
through the fields, along the street. You could lean into turns and
feel the wind in your face. You could speed down hills and fly off the
curb. It was wonderful and exhilirating. Once you learned to ride
without the training wheels, you never wanted or needed them again.
Are you living your life with the training wheels on? Are you nestled
safely inside your comfort zone, with your job and your mortgage and
your HMO and your daily routine keeping you nice and secure? Do you
even know what you're missing?
Is your fear keeping you from following your dreams? What are you
afraid of? Going after your biggest dream is no more difficult than
safely living inside your comfort zone. And it is infinitely more
rewarding.
Riding your bicycle without the training wheels soon became even
easier than riding with them on, and a whole lot more fun. You never
would have known that, though, if you had not tried.
Are you too afraid to take the training wheels off? What's the worst
that can happen? The worst that can happen, will happen for sure if
you DON'T take them off. The worst that can happen is that you'll get
to the end of your life never having known the excitement of challenge
or the thrill of accomplishment.
Make the commitment today to grab those handlebars and head out on the
road of life! |
|