Understanding the Family Business
The family business is a vital force in the economy. more than 60
percent of all businesses are family owned or controlled. They range in
size from the traditional small business to a third of the Fortune 500
firms. It is estimated that family businesses generate about half of the
country's Gross National Product and half of the total wages paid.
Our economy depends heavily on the continuity and success of the family
business. It is unfortunate, even alarming, that such a vital force has
such a poor survival rate. Less than one third of family businesses
survive the transition from first to second generation ownership. Of those
that do, about half do not survive the transition from second to third
generation ownership.
At any given time, 40 percent of businesses are facing the transfer of
ownership issue. Founders are trying to decide what to do with their
businesses; however, the options are few. The following is a list of
options to consider:
- Close the doors.
- Sell to an outsider or employee.
- Retain ownership but hire outside management.
- Retain family ownership and management control.
To be one of the few family businesses that survive transfer of
ownership requires a good understanding of your business and your family.
There are four basic reasons why family firms fail to transfer the
business from generation to generation successfully:
- Lack of viability of the business.
- Lack of planning.
- Little desire on the owner's part to transfer the firm.
- Reluctance of offspring to join the firm.
These factors, alone or in combination, make transferring a family
business difficult, if not impossible. The primary cause for failure,
however, is the lack of planning. With the right plans in place, the
business, in most cases, will remain healthy. There are four plans that
make up the transition process. By implementing these plans, you will
virtually ensure the successful transfer of your business within the
family hierarchy.
A brief explanation of each plan follows.
- A strategic plan for the business will allow each generation an
opportunity to chart a course for the firm. Setting business goals as a
family will ensure that everyone has a clear picture of the company's
future.
- The family strategic plan is needed to maintain a healthy, viable
business. This plan establishes policies for the family's role in the
business. For example, it may include an entry and exit policy that
outlines the criteria for working in the business. It should include the
creed or mission statement that spells out your family's values and basic
policies for the business. The family strategic plan will address other
issues that are important to your family. By implementing this plan, you
may avoid later conflicts about compensation, sibling rivalry, ownership
and management control.
- A succession plan will ease the founding or current generation's
concerns about transferring the firm. It outlines how succession will
occur and how to know when the successor is ready. Many founders do not
want to let go of the company because they are afraid the successors are
not prepared, or they are afraid to be without a job. Often, heirs sense
this reluctance and plan an alternative career. If, however, the heirs see
a plan in place that outlines the succession process, they may be more apt
to continue in the family business.
- An estate plan is critical for the family and the business. Without
it, you will pay higher estate taxes than necessary. Taking the time to
develop an estate plan ensures that your estate goes primarily to your
heirs rather than to taxes.
For business owners who do little planning, the idea of preparing four
plans may seem overwhelming. Although it is not easy, the commitment made
by all family members during the planning process is the key ingredient
for business continuity and success. The first rule for successfully
operating and transferring the family firm is: Share information with all
family members, active and nonactive. By doing this, you will eliminate
problems that arise when decisions are made and implemented without the
knowledge and counsel of all family members.
UNDERSTANDING THE FAMILY BUSINESS
This section will explore the nature of the family business as a dual
operating system, and will identify issues of greatest concern to family
business owners, as identified by family business owners across the
country. As you review these issues, you will see that, although you and
your family are unique, the challenges you face are not, because almost
every family business shares the same problems.
Also, perspectives of the individuals involved in a family business
will be presented. We tend to confuse personality with
perspective--understanding the viewpoints of the different actors involved
in the family business (active and nonactive) can help alleviate conflicts
that may arise.
What Is a Family Business?
Defined simply, a family business is any business in which a majority
of the ownership or control lies within a family, and in which two or more
family members are directly involved. It is also a complex, dual system
consisting of the family and the business; family members involved in the
business are part of a task system (the business) and part of a family
system. These two systems overlap. This is where conflict may occur
because each system has its own rules, roles and requirements. For
example, the family system is an emotional one, stressing relationships
and rewarding loyalty with love and with care. Entry into this system is
by birth, and membership is permanent. The role you have in the
family--husband/father, wife/mother, child/brother/sister--carries with it
certain responsibilities and expectations. In addition, families have
their own style of communicating and resolving conflicts, which they have
spent years perfecting. These styles may be good for family situations but
may not be the best ways to resolve business conflicts.
Conversely, the business system is unemotional and contractually based.
Entry is based on experience, expertise and potential. Membership is
contingent upon performance, and performance is rewarded materially. Like
the family system, roles in the business, such as president, manager,
employee and stockholder/owner, carry specific responsibilities and
expectations. And like the home environment, businesses have their own
communication, conflict resolution and decision-making styles.
Conflicts arise when roles assumed in one system intrude on roles in
the other, when communication patterns used in one system are used in the
other or when there are conflicts of interest between the two systems. For
example, a conflict may arise between parent and child, between siblings
or between a husband and wife when roles assumed in the business system
carry over to the family system. The boss and employee roles a husband and
wife might assume at work most likely will not be appropriate as at-home
roles. Alternatively, a role assumed in the family may not work well in
the business. For instance, offspring who are the peace makers at home may
find themselves mediating management conflicts between family members
whether or not they have the desire or qualifications to do so.
A special case of role carryover may occur when an individual is
continually cast in a particular role. This happens primarily to children.
Everyone grows up with a label: the good one, the black sheep, the smart
one. While a person may outgrow a label, the family often perceives that
person as still carrying the attribute. This perception may affect the way
that person operates in the business.
Family communication patterns don't always affect the business, but
when they do it can be very embarrassing. Often you say things to family
members in a way you would never speak to other employees or managers.
This problem is compounded when your communication is misread by the
family member. Often parents are surprised by a son's or daughter's
negative reaction to a business directive or performance evaluation. This
reaction is probably because the individual perceived the instructions or
evaluation as orders or criticism from Dad or Mom, not from the boss.
System overlap is apparent when conflicts of interest arise between the
family and the business. Some families put personal concerns before
business concerns instead of trying to achieve a balance between the two.
It is important to understand that the family's strong emotional
attachments and overriding sense of loyalty to each other create unique
management situations. For example, solving a family problem, such as
giving an unemployable or incompetent relative a position in the firm,
ignores the company's personnel needs but meets the needs of family
loyalty.
Another example of conflict of interest occurs when business owners
feel that giving children equal salaries is fair. Siblings who have more
responsibility but receive the same pay as those with less responsibility
usually resent it. In cases of sibling rivalry, it isn't unusual for one
sibling to withhold information from another or try to engage in power
plays, i.e., behaviors that can be detrimental to the firm.
Much of this behavior can be eliminated or managed by devising policies
that meet the needs of both the family and the business. Developing these
policies is part of the family strategic planning process. Before
discussing them, you should make sure you have identified all the issues
that need to be addressed.
Issues in the Family Business
The list below contains the issues that most family businesses face:
Participation--who can participate in the family business and
under what circumstances.
Leadership and ownership--how to prepare the next generation to
assume responsibility for the business.
Letting go--how to help the entrepreneur let go of the family
business.
Liquidity and estate taxes.
Attracting and retaining nonfamily executives.
Compensation of family members--equality versus merit.
Successors--who chooses and how to choose among multiple
successors.
Strengthening family harmony.
All of these issues and the others you include in the Family Business
Assessment Inventory can potentially cause business conflict and family
stress. But there are three steps you can take to manage conflict and
stress in a family business:
Identify issues that may cause conflict and stress. Discuss these
issues with the family. Devise a policy to address them.
Who Are the Actors?
The next consideration in understanding the family business is to
understand the perspectives of those involved. Without this understanding,
managing a family business will be difficult.
The actors in the family business can be divided into two groups: (1)
family members and (2) nonfamily members. Each group has its own
perspective and set of concerns and is capable of exerting pressures
within the family and the firm.
Family Members
Neither an Employee nor an Owner - Children and in-laws are usually
in this group. Although they may not be part of the business operations,
they can exert pressure within the family that affects the business. For
example, children may resent the time a parent spends in the business.
This creates a problem because parents usually develop guilt feelings as a
result of their neglect and the resentment expressed by the children.
In-laws, on the other hand, are viewed either as outsiders and intruders
or as allies and therefore are usually ignored or misunderstood. For
example, a daughter-in-law is usually expected to support her husband's
efforts in the business without a clear understanding of family or
business dynamics. She may contribute to family problems or find herself
in the middle of a family struggle. The son-in-law faces similar, if not
worse, problems. He may be placed in a competitive situation with his
wife's brothers. If he isn't involved in the family business, he can still
exert pressure on the business in his role as his wife's confidant.
An Employee but not an Owner - This family member works in the
business but does not have an ownership position. For this individual,
conflict may arise for a number of reasons.
For example, if he or she compares himself or herself to the family
member who has an ownership position but is not an employee, a sense of
inequity may result. The member may voice his or her resentment: I'm doing
all the work, and they just sit back and get all the profits. Or
resentment may occur when decisions are made by owners alone. Here, he or
she may feel: I'm working here every day. I know how decisions are going
to affect the company. Why didn't they ask me? Family members employed in
or associated with a family business generally expect to be treated
differently from nonfamily employees.
An Employee and an Owner - This individual may have the most
difficult position. He or she must effectively handle all the actors in
both systems. As an owner, he or she is responsible for the well-being and
continuance of the business, as well as the daily business operations. He
or she must deal with the concerns of both family and nonfamily employees.
Often, the founder, as the sole owner and chief executive, falls in this
category.
Not an Employee but an Owner - This group usually consists of
siblings and retired relatives. Their major concern usually is the income
provided by the business; thus, anything that threatens their security may
cause conflict. For example, if the managing owners want to pursue a
growth strategy that will consume cash and has an element of risk, they
may face resistance from retired relatives who are concerned primarily
about dividend payments.
Nonfamily Members
An Employee but not an Owner - This group deals with the issues of
nepotism and coalition building and the effects of family conflicts on
daily operations. Owners' concerns for nonowner employees usually involve
recruiting and motivating nonfamily employees and nonfamily owner-managers
who will have little or no opportunity for advancement, accepting children
of nonfamily managers into the business and minimizing political moves
that support family members over nonowner employees.
An Employee and an Owner - With the emergence of stock-option
plans, this group has become more important. Employees may become owners
during a succession. In companies where a successor has been chosen,
partial ownership of the company by its employees can foster cooperation
with the new management because the employees will personally share the
benefits and responsibilities of the company. In cases where there is no
successor, selling the company to the employees who have helped build it
makes good business sense. Employees who own the company will want to be
treated like owners, which may be difficult for family members to
understand and accept. A thorough understanding of the behavioral
consequences of an employee stock ownership program (ESOP) should be
grasped before a family implements such a program. Understanding the
perspective of the individuals around you, both family and nonfamily, will
make communicating and decision making easier.
Food For Thought
Have you ever been so far
down that you don't see how you can ever get out of it? Do you have
problems that seem to overwhelm you? How do you come back from
something like that? How do you move forward with your life?
Just remember this. No matter what has happened in the past, you
always have something to contribute to life. As long as you are
breathing, you can make a difference. It doesn't matter who you are or
what you have been, or even what you have done. That is all in the
past, and you cannot change it, but you can change the present and the
future.
You can resolve to make a positive contribution to life -- to your own
life, to the lives of others, to your community, to the world, to the
future. Nothing can pull you down far enough when you are resolved to
make a difference, when you are committed to making a contribution.
Go foward. Find what you can contribute to life, and you will find
fulfillment, joy and peace.
Friday morning we had a wonderful thunderstorm at sunrise that knocked
out electrical power to 12,000 homes for about 2 hours.
After the storm had subsided, but before the power was restored, I sat
alone in the house and was overcome with the quietness that was around
me. Under normal circumstances, "quiet" means having the TV and stereo
off, and the kids in bed. But the absence of electricity took "quiet"
to a new level. No hum of the refrigerator or rumble of the air
conditioner. No whine of disk drives and cooling fans from the
computer system. The only sound was the occasional drip of water off
the roof. I realized that what I normally thought of as quiet was
really quite noisy.
And sitting there in the quietness, I experienced a stunning clarity
of awareness. With my mind freed from having to process all those
normal, everyday sounds, there was capacity available to actually
think. And it made me wonder... What other kinds of "noise" do we get
used to? And what does that noise block from our awareness? Sometimes
it is useful to step away from all the noise in order to remember that
there's someone here inside.
If I sat down to write a 150 page book on personal development, I
would not know where to begin. The task in front of me would appear
daunting. And yet, in the last few months, that's exactly what I've
done. Writing this column each day, a few paragraphs a day, I've put
together a large amount of information. It seems like only yesterday
that I started (it was November 1, 1995).
There is enormous power in the things you do consistently -- day after
day after day, focused in the same direction. Remember the story of
the tortise and the hare? Consistency will win out over brute force
and speed just about any day. If you start too fast you'll burn out
long before you reach your goal. Even if it were possible to have it
all immediately, where would be the joy and the sense of
accomplishment in that?
Instead, make time your friend. Pace yourself. Leave a little bit
undone each day so there will be something to get you started
tomorrow. More importantly, keep yourself focused and traveling in the
direction of your dreams. Resolve to write one chapter a day in the
book of your life. Before long, you'll have a masterpiece. |